Skip to content
Home » The Downside of Investing in High-Rise Developments in Malaysia

The Downside of Investing in High-Rise Developments in Malaysia

    In recent years, high-rise developments have become a dominant feature of Malaysia’s urban landscape. As the country’s population grows and city spaces become more crowded, developers have turned to vertical living solutions, particularly in key areas like Mont Kiara, Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC), and surrounding urban hotspots. These towering skyscrapers promise luxury living, stunning views, and close proximity to city conveniences, attracting a wide range of buyers, from young professionals to foreign investors.

    However, the allure of high-rise properties isn’t without its downsides. While some investors continue to flock to these developments, driven by the hope of capital appreciation and rental returns, the reality often presents a more complex picture. Issues such as market oversupply, skyrocketing maintenance fees, and shrinking capital gains have begun to erode the appeal of high-rise investments, especially in saturated areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC.

    In this article, we will take an in-depth look at the challenges faced by investors in Malaysia’s high-rise market. From understanding the dynamics of oversupply to grappling with the financial burden of high upkeep costs, this article will explore the less glamorous side of investing in high-rise developments and offer insight into why the promised returns may not always materialize.

    The Downside of Investing in High-Rise Developments in Malaysia

    Oversupply of High-Rise Units

    One of the most significant challenges facing investors in Malaysia’s high-rise property market is oversupply. Over the past decade, rapid urban development and a growing influx of foreign investment have driven developers to construct more high-rise residential units, particularly in popular areas like Mont Kiara, KLCC, Bangsar South, and Bukit Bintang. This surge in supply, however, has outpaced demand, leading to an excess of unsold units.

    Definition of Oversupply

    Oversupply occurs when there are more available units on the market than there are buyers or renters. In Malaysia, this phenomenon is particularly evident in luxury high-rise developments, where the number of newly completed projects continues to increase, even as the pool of potential buyers remains stagnant or shrinks.

    Impact on Property Prices

    When there are too many available units, competition among sellers and landlords intensifies. This creates downward pressure on property prices and rental yields, as owners are forced to lower prices to attract buyers or tenants. For instance, the sheer volume of available units means that buyers have more options, driving prices down as sellers compete to offload their properties.

    Shrinking Capital Appreciation

    Another downside of investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia, particularly in saturated areas like Mont Kiara and Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC), is the shrinking capital appreciation. While high-rise properties in these prime locations once offered significant returns on investment, the market has shifted. Investors who bought into these developments expecting strong capital growth are now facing a reality where appreciation is either minimal or, in some cases, stagnant.

    Early Boom vs Current Trend

    In the early 2000s, areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC saw rapid capital appreciation, driven by high demand from expatriates, foreign investors, and affluent local buyers. These neighborhoods became synonymous with luxury living, and property prices skyrocketed as more developments were launched. Investors who entered the market during this boom experienced substantial returns on their investments.

    However, in recent years, the trend has changed. With the market now saturated with high-rise projects, the opportunity for significant capital appreciation has diminished. The supply of units has outpaced demand, leading to price stagnation. Many investors who bought into newer developments with the expectation of double-digit appreciation are finding that their properties have either plateaued or appreciated at a much slower rate than anticipated.

    Reasons for Shrinking Returns

    Several factors contribute to the shrinking capital appreciation in Malaysia’s high-rise market:

    • Market saturation: As mentioned in the previous section, the oversupply of high-rise units has led to increased competition among sellers, driving prices down.
    • Limited land space: Developers in urban centers have little room to expand horizontally, so they continue to build vertically. This has resulted in an abundance of high-rise projects, limiting the potential for price growth in any single development.
    • Global economic factors: Economic uncertainties, coupled with changes in foreign investment policies, have also played a role in reducing demand for high-end properties, further affecting capital appreciation.

    High Maintenance Fees

    One of the often-overlooked downsides of investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia is the significant burden of high maintenance fees. These fees, which are meant to cover the upkeep and operation of shared facilities and services, can erode the profitability of an investment, particularly when they increase over time. For investors who are already dealing with shrinking capital appreciation and an oversupplied market, high maintenance fees can add an additional financial strain.

    Overview of Maintenance Fees

    Maintenance fees in high-rise developments typically cover a range of expenses, including:

    • Security services.
    • Upkeep of common areas like swimming pools, gyms, and gardens.
    • Repairs and maintenance of shared infrastructure (elevators, parking lots, etc.).
    • Management staff salaries and operational costs.
    • Increasing cost of electricity tariff

    These fees are generally calculated on a per-square-foot basis, meaning larger units or developments with more luxurious facilities can carry higher fees. In premium areas, where high-rise developments often come with a variety of amenities, these fees can be substantial.

    Factors Contributing to High Fees

    Several factors drive up maintenance costs in high-rise buildings, especially in luxury developments:

    • Premium facilities: Many high-rise developments offer residents access to a wide array of facilities such as infinity pools, rooftop gardens, concierge services, and private gyms. While these amenities add value to the property, they also come with high upkeep costs, which are passed on to owners.
    • Larger developments: The size of a high-rise project can also impact maintenance fees. Larger developments with more units often require more extensive management and maintenance, increasing the overall costs for residents.
    • Aging infrastructure: Older high-rise buildings tend to require more frequent repairs and updates, such as elevator replacements or water system upgrades. These costs add up over time and are reflected in rising maintenance fees.

    Comparison: High-Rise vs Landed Property Maintenance Fees

    To provide context, high-rise properties, especially in premium areas, tend to have significantly higher maintenance fees compared to landed properties. For instance, a high-rise condominium in Mont Kiara could charge RM0.35 to RM0.50 per square foot in maintenance fees, meaning a 1,500 sq. ft. unit might cost RM525 to RM750 per month. In contrast, landed properties often have lower fees, primarily because there are fewer shared amenities to maintain.

    Older high-rise developments might initially offer lower fees, but as buildings age and require more upkeep, fees can rise dramatically. Conversely, newer high-rise projects often start with lower fees, but as time goes on, the need for maintenance and repairs can increase, leading to higher costs for residents.

    Financial Burden on Investors

    For investors, high maintenance fees represent a significant ongoing cost that can eat into rental yields and overall profitability. In high-rise properties with large common areas and premium facilities, the high monthly maintenance costs can make it difficult to generate positive cash flow, especially if the property is already facing stagnant rental rates due to oversupply.

    Furthermore, if rental yields are low—as they are often in oversaturated markets l – the burden of maintenance fees can make the investment unappealing. Owners may find themselves paying substantial sums each month without generating enough rental income to cover those expenses.

    High maintenance fees can also become a deterrent for potential buyers or tenants. In a market where affordability is becoming more of a priority, prospective buyers may avoid high-rise developments with excessive fees, preferring either older, less expensive condos or landed properties with lower costs.

    Challenging Rental Market

    Another critical downside of investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia, particularly in prime areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC, is the increasingly competitive and challenging rental market. Investors who purchase high-rise units with the intention of renting them out often face difficulties in securing tenants at desirable rental rates, resulting in lower-than-expected rental yields and extended periods of vacancy.

    Tenant Demand vs Availability

    The oversupply of high-rise units in popular urban areas has created a situation where there are more units available for rent than there are tenants to fill them. While these areas were once hotspots for expatriates and foreign professionals, changes in visa regulations and economic shifts have reduced the number of potential tenants seeking luxury high-rise units in locations like Mont Kiara and KLCC.

    With a growing number of high-rise developments competing for a shrinking pool of tenants, landlords are often forced to lower their asking prices or offer additional incentives, such as free months of rent, to attract tenants. This increased competition can be especially challenging in areas where many similar units are available, making it harder for landlords to distinguish their properties from the rest.

    Rental Rate Stagnation

    As a result of this oversupply and increased competition, rental rates in high-rise developments have largely stagnated, particularly in luxury segments. Despite rising costs of living and inflation, many high-rise property owners are unable to increase their rental rates without risking prolonged vacancies. This stagnation in rental income directly impacts the overall profitability of the investment.

    In Mont Kiara, for example, rental rates for luxury condominiums have seen minimal growth over the past few years. Even though property prices and maintenance fees continue to rise, rental rates have remained flat, reducing the net returns for landlords. A similar trend can be observed in KLCC, where high-end units face fierce competition from newer, more modern developments.

    Vacancy Periods and Their Impact

    Extended vacancy periods are another major issue facing investors in high-rise developments. In oversupplied markets, it can take months, or even longer, to secure tenants, particularly for larger or more expensive units. During these periods, landlords are still responsible for paying maintenance fees, property taxes, and other associated costs, all while receiving no rental income.

    This situation can quickly turn a seemingly profitable investment into a financial drain. For investors relying on rental income to cover mortgage payments or other expenses, prolonged vacancies can create cash flow problems and make it difficult to sustain the investment over the long term.

    Factors Driving Rental Market Challenges

    Several factors contribute to the increasingly difficult rental market for high-rise developments in Malaysia:

    • Declining expatriate population: Government policy changes, such as stricter visa regulations and adjustments to the Malaysia My Second Home (MM2H) program, have reduced the number of expatriates in key urban areas. Many high-rise developments, particularly in Mont Kiara, relied heavily on expatriate tenants, and the decline in this tenant pool has had a direct impact on rental demand.
    • Tenant preference for newer developments: With new high-rise projects continually being launched, tenants often prefer to rent newer units that offer modern facilities and infrastructure, leaving older properties with fewer prospective renters.
    • Economic uncertainties: Global economic conditions, such as recessions or shifts in currency exchange rates, can also influence the rental market, particularly for luxury units that tend to attract international tenants.

    Depreciating Appeal of Older High-Rise Developments

    As Malaysia’s property market continues to evolve, one of the major challenges investors face is the depreciating appeal of older high-rise developments. High-rise buildings, especially those in prime locations such as Mont Kiara and Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC), may initially attract strong interest from buyers and tenants due to their modern amenities and prime location. However, as newer and more advanced projects emerge, older developments often struggle to retain their value and appeal. This depreciation can have significant consequences for both rental demand and resale value.

    Competition with Newer Projects

    The high-rise property market in Malaysia is highly competitive, with new projects constantly being launched. These newer developments often come equipped with state-of-the-art facilities, innovative design features, and advanced technologies, which can make older high-rise buildings seem outdated by comparison. This is especially true in areas like KLCC and Mont Kiara, where luxury living is a major selling point.

    For example, a high-rise condo built a decade ago may offer basic amenities like a gym, swimming pool, and security services. In contrast, a new development in the same area might boast additional features such as co-working spaces, rooftop infinity pools, smart home systems, and green building certifications. As a result, tenants and buyers are more likely to be drawn to these newer projects, leaving older developments struggling to attract interest.

    This competitive disadvantage is particularly acute in premium locations, where residents expect the highest standards of living. Even if older high-rise units are located in prime areas, they can still lose out to more modern options that offer a better living experience.

    Aging Facilities and Maintenance

    Another issue that impacts the appeal of older high-rise developments is the natural wear and tear of facilities over time. As buildings age, their infrastructure—such as elevators, plumbing, electrical systems, and security features—requires more frequent maintenance and repairs. While developers and management bodies typically address these issues, the overall experience for residents in older buildings may still decline.

    In some cases, the costs of upgrading and maintaining aging facilities can lead to rising maintenance fees, further diminishing the appeal of these properties for both tenants and buyers. For example, an older high-rise development in Mont Kiara may require significant renovation to its common areas or structural components, resulting in higher maintenance fees that owners must bear. These increased costs can deter potential tenants, who may prefer to rent in newer buildings with lower fees and fewer maintenance issues.

    Reduced Aesthetic Appeal

    As time goes on, the aesthetic appeal of older high-rise buildings may also diminish. In a competitive market like Kuala Lumpur, where sleek, modern designs are highly valued, older buildings may appear outdated or less visually attractive compared to their newer counterparts. This can have a direct impact on both resale value and rental demand.

    For instance, an older condominium with dated architecture and interior design may struggle to compete with nearby developments offering contemporary, minimalist designs that appeal to a younger, more design-conscious demographic. While aesthetic renovations are possible, they often require significant investment from property owners or management bodies, which may not always be feasible.

    The Long-Term Impact on Resale Value

    For investors, the depreciating appeal of older high-rise developments presents a serious concern when it comes to resale value. Properties in prime areas may still hold some intrinsic value due to their location, but the gap between newer and older developments continues to widen. In the long term, this can result in a lower resale price than originally expected, especially if the property requires significant renovations to remain competitive.

    In some cases, older high-rise units may even struggle to find buyers, particularly in oversaturated markets. Investors who purchased these properties with the expectation of capital appreciation may find themselves holding onto their units for longer than anticipated, or having to sell at a loss.

    Volatility in the Property Market

    Investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia also exposes investors to the volatility of the property market. This volatility can be caused by a range of factors, including economic fluctuations, changing government policies, and shifts in foreign buyer trends. While property markets globally experience ups and downs, the high-rise segment, especially in urban centers like Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC) and Mont Kiara, is particularly susceptible to market shifts due to its dependence on both local and foreign demand.

    Economic Factors

    The Malaysian economy plays a significant role in the performance of the property market, and high-rise developments are often directly affected by economic fluctuations. Economic downturns, rising interest rates, and inflation can all lead to reduced demand for high-end property investments. When economic conditions are unfavorable, potential buyers and tenants may become more conservative in their spending, opting for more affordable housing options rather than high-rise condominiums in luxury areas.

    For example, during periods of economic uncertainty, such as the global financial crisis of 2008 or the COVID-19 pandemic, the property market in Malaysia experienced a slowdown. This was particularly evident in the luxury segment of the market, where demand for high-rise units dropped as both local and foreign buyers tightened their budgets.

    Foreign Ownership Trends

    Malaysia’s high-rise developments have historically attracted a significant portion of foreign buyers, particularly in premium areas like KLCC, Mont Kiara, and Bangsar. Foreigners are drawn to these areas for their modern amenities, prime locations, and international appeal. However, changes in foreign ownership policies can have a direct impact on the demand for high-rise properties.

    For instance, the Malaysian government periodically adjusts the minimum purchase price for foreign buyers, as well as policies under the Malaysia My Second Home (MM2H) program. In recent years, the minimum price threshold for foreign property buyers was increased in many states, limiting the number of foreigners who can afford to invest in high-end developments. Additionally, stricter rules under the MM2H program have led to a decrease in foreign interest in Malaysian properties, further contributing to volatility in the market.

    When foreign interest declines, the luxury high-rise market is often one of the hardest-hit segments. Investors who rely on foreign buyers to purchase their units or tenants to rent their properties may find it challenging to achieve their desired returns.

    Uncertainty in the Luxury Segment

    High-rise developments in areas like KLCC and Mont Kiara cater predominantly to the luxury market. While luxury properties can offer significant returns during periods of economic prosperity, they are also more vulnerable to market downturns and external economic factors. For example, a recession or a global economic slowdown can reduce demand for high-end properties, as both local and foreign buyers shift their focus to more affordable housing options.

    Additionally, the luxury market tends to experience more pronounced price corrections during economic downturns. As buyers and investors become more risk-averse, the prices of luxury condominiums in prime locations may drop faster and more significantly than those of mid-range or affordable properties.

    The Impact of Political and Policy Changes

    In addition to economic factors, changes in government policies or political instability can also contribute to property market volatility. For example, shifts in government policy regarding property taxes, foreign investment regulations, or housing affordability initiatives can all influence the demand for high-rise developments.

    Malaysia’s political landscape has seen some uncertainty in recent years, with changes in government leadership and evolving policies on housing. Policies aimed at cooling down the property market or addressing housing affordability can lead to temporary slowdowns in high-end property investments. For example, the government’s focus on affordable housing initiatives may reduce the number of incentives available for luxury property developers, thereby affecting investor sentiment in the high-rise market.

    Managing Risk in a Volatile Market

    Investors looking to mitigate the risks of market volatility in high-rise developments should consider several strategies:

    • Diversification: Instead of concentrating investments solely in luxury high-rise units, investors can diversify their portfolios by including mid-range or affordable housing developments, which tend to be more resilient during economic downturns.
    • Monitoring Government Policies: Keeping a close eye on changes to government policies, particularly those related to foreign investment, property taxes, and housing affordability, can help investors make more informed decisions.
    • Timing the Market: While it is difficult to predict market shifts, investors can improve their chances of success by timing their investments based on economic and political cycles, entering the market when conditions are favorable and exiting during periods of uncertainty.

    Hidden Costs for Investors

    Investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia is not just about the initial purchase price. There are several hidden costs that can significantly impact an investor’s returns over time. These costs can sometimes catch investors off guard, especially if they are not fully accounted for in the financial planning process. From ongoing renovation expenses to vacancy costs, understanding these hidden expenses is crucial for any investor considering high-rise properties in areas like Mont Kiara or Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC).

    Renovation and Upgrading Costs

    One of the biggest hidden costs in high-rise property investment is the need for renovations and upgrades. As high-rise buildings age, units may require periodic updates to remain competitive in the rental and resale markets. This is especially true for older properties in areas like Mont Kiara, where newer developments with modern facilities and design features can easily overshadow outdated units.

    Investors may need to spend on:

    • Cosmetic upgrades: Repainting, new flooring, or updating kitchens and bathrooms to attract tenants or buyers.
    • Structural repairs: Fixing leaks, upgrading electrical systems, or replacing windows and air conditioning units in older buildings.
    • Furnishings: In Malaysia, many high-rise units are rented fully or partially furnished. As styles change and furniture wears out, investors will need to refresh the unit to keep it appealing.

    The cost of these upgrades can add up over time, especially if the property is being rented out and requires regular upkeep to remain attractive to tenants.

    Vacancy Costs

    Vacancy periods represent another hidden cost that can significantly impact an investor’s bottom line. In oversupplied markets like Mont Kiara and KLCC, where competition for tenants is fierce, it’s not uncommon for units to sit empty for months. During these periods, investors still have to bear the cost of maintaining the unit, paying maintenance fees, property taxes, and possibly mortgage repayments, all while generating no rental income.

    Vacancies can be caused by:

    • Market saturation: As mentioned earlier, the oversupply of high-rise units in some areas makes it harder to find tenants quickly, leading to longer vacancy periods.
    • Price expectations: Investors may overestimate the rental value of their unit, pricing it too high and resulting in extended periods without tenants.
    • Unit condition: Properties that haven’t been updated or maintained to modern standards may struggle to attract tenants, prolonging vacancies.

    For investors relying on rental income to cover mortgage payments or other expenses, prolonged vacancies can quickly erode profits and lead to financial strain.

    Management Fees for Rental Properties

    For investors who do not live near their investment properties or do not have the time to manage them, hiring a property management company is a common solution. These companies handle tasks such as tenant screening, rent collection, and maintenance coordination. However, these services come at a cost, typically ranging from 5% to 10% of the monthly rental income.

    In addition to management fees, some companies charge extra for:

    • Tenant placement fees: A one-time fee for finding a new tenant.
    • Maintenance mark-ups: Extra charges for coordinating repairs or upgrades.

    While property management can be a lifesaver for remote or busy investors, the additional costs can reduce overall rental yields, especially in high-rise developments where rental rates may already be stagnant.

    Service Charges and Taxes

    Investors also need to be aware of ongoing service charges and taxes associated with owning high-rise properties. These costs include:

    • Quit rent (cukai tanah): A land tax levied annually on property owners in Malaysia, the amount of which is determined by the size and location of the property.
    • Assessment tax (cukai taksiran): A local property tax paid to the local municipal council, based on the annual rental value of the property.
    • Utilities: For rental properties, some landlords cover the cost of utilities (such as water and electricity) during vacancy periods or as part of tenant incentives. This adds to the cost of ownership.

    The cumulative effect of these recurring costs can significantly impact the profitability of an investment, especially in high-rise developments where maintenance fees and other charges are already high.

    Capital Gains Tax

    Investors also need to consider Malaysia’s Real Property Gains Tax (RPGT), which applies to profits made from selling a property. For high-rise property investors, this tax can cut into potential capital gains when selling the property. RPGT rates vary depending on how long the property has been held:

    • Within 5 years of purchase: Higher rates of RPGT are applied, especially in the first 3 years.
    • Beyond 5 years: The tax rate reduces but still applies, which can impact the total return on investment.

    Balancing Risk and Reward: Is High-Rise Investment in Malaysia Still Worth It?

    Investing in high-rise developments in Malaysia, especially in prime areas like Mont Kiara and Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC), can be a double-edged sword. While these properties may offer the allure of luxury living and proximity to urban conveniences, the reality for investors is far more complex. The downsides, including market oversupply, shrinking capital appreciation, high maintenance fees, and the volatility of the property market, create significant risks that need to be carefully evaluated.

    Key Takeaways

    • Oversupply: The oversaturation of high-rise developments in urban centers has led to a significant imbalance between supply and demand, causing property prices to stagnate and reducing rental yields. In areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC, investors are faced with a surplus of unsold units, which has created stiff competition among sellers and landlords.
    • Shrinking Capital Appreciation: High-rise properties in previously lucrative areas are no longer experiencing the rapid appreciation they once did. The market has matured, and with a surplus of new developments entering the market, investors are seeing slower growth in property values, or in some cases, stagnation.
    • High Maintenance Fees: The cost of maintaining high-rise properties, particularly those with premium facilities and aging infrastructure, is another financial burden that investors must bear. These fees can significantly reduce the profitability of rental income and add long-term financial strain.
    • Challenging Rental Market: The rental market for high-rise units is increasingly competitive, especially in oversupplied areas. Stagnant rental rates and prolonged vacancy periods make it difficult for investors to achieve desirable yields, particularly if the property requires upgrades to remain competitive.
    • Depreciating Appeal of Older Developments: Older high-rise properties face growing competition from newer, more modern developments, which often offer better amenities and appeal to tenants and buyers. As a result, older properties may experience depreciation in both rental demand and resale value.
    • Market Volatility: External factors such as economic downturns, changing foreign ownership policies, and political uncertainty can create volatility in the high-rise property market. Investors who depend on foreign buyers or tenants are particularly vulnerable to these shifts.
    • Hidden Costs: Beyond the initial purchase price, investors must be prepared for ongoing hidden costs, including renovation expenses, vacancy costs, property management fees, and taxes. These can all erode the overall profitability of a high-rise investment.

    Is High-Rise Investment Still Viable?

    Despite these challenges, high-rise investments are not without their merits. For those with a long-term investment horizon and the ability to weather periods of market volatility, there is still potential for growth, particularly in well-maintained, strategically located developments. However, the days of guaranteed high returns from high-rise properties in areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC appear to be over, and investors must now approach this market with caution and a realistic understanding of the risks involved.

    Alternative Strategies for Property Investors

    • Consider Landed Properties: Investors looking for more stable long-term returns might consider landed properties, which tend to have lower maintenance fees and less market saturation compared to high-rise developments.
    • Look at Emerging Areas: Instead of focusing on saturated urban centers, investors could explore emerging areas that are still undergoing development. These areas may offer better capital appreciation potential and less competition in the rental market.
    • Mixed-Use Developments: Mixed-use properties, which combine residential units with commercial spaces, can provide diversified income streams and potentially better returns.
    • Mid-Range Properties: Shifting focus to mid-range properties, which appeal to a broader demographic, can also help investors achieve more consistent rental demand and minimize the risks associated with luxury high-rise units.

    Final Thoughts

    For investors considering high-rise developments in Malaysia, particularly in premium areas like Mont Kiara and KLCC, it is essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully. While these properties once symbolized strong investment opportunities, market saturation, shrinking appreciation, and high costs have made it increasingly difficult to achieve substantial returns. To succeed in this market, investors must remain informed, flexible, and prepared to navigate the evolving landscape of Malaysia’s property sector.

    By understanding the potential downsides and planning accordingly, investors can still find opportunities in Malaysia’s high-rise market, but those opportunities may require a more strategic, long-term approach than in previous years.